Protocol: ARCIC 132
Author/editor(s): P.J. Fitzpatrick
Creation: 6 June 1975 (The date of original creation or publication, if known)
Size/extent: 39 + 1 pages; A4

Persistent link: https://iarccum.org/doc/479 (Please use this permanent URL in your publications and bookmarks to link to this document. The files linked below may be modified, but this record will remain at this location.)

Includes a portion of the introduction as well as sections 4–6 of chapter 5 of P.J. Fitzpatrick‘s In the Breaking of the Bread, a book expected to be published soon thereafter. A covering letter from Bishop Alan Clark is included that provides some context for these sections within the rest of chapter 5. The first record of publication of Fitzpatrick‘s book appears to be in 1993 (Cambridge University Press) with the slightly revised title In Breaking of Bread: The Eucharist and Ritual.

Further research under the pseudonym G. Egner reveals other contemporaneous essays on transubstantiation:

• “Some Thoughts on the Eucharistic Presence: 1“, New Blackfriars 53, no. 627 (Aug. 1972): 354–359 (https://www.jstor.org/stable/43245797)
• “More Thoughts on the Eucharistic Presence“, New Blackfriars 54, no. 635 (April 1973): 171–180 (https://www.jstor.org/stable/43245920)

These essays critical of Aquinas‘ doctrine of transubstantiation were published together with materials defending Aquinas written by the New Blackfriars editor, Herbert McCabe. The entire exchange was re–published by McCabe in his book God Matters (Continuum, 1987), see ch. 4, pp. 115–180.